This might have been discussed to death by now, unfortunately I couldn’t find any discussion on it on Lemmy. Though I would love to be corrected on that!

How does an always on incognito Chromium with uBlock Origin on medium mode (and other hardening/privacy settings enabled) compare to Brave (with e.g. Privacy Guides’ recommended settings) with respect to security and privacy on Linux[1]?

Commonly heard whataboutisms:

  • “With the looming advent of Manifest v3, this discussion might not be very relevant for long.” I’m aware.
  • “Just use Firefox/Librewolf or any other privacy-conscious browser that isn’t Chromium-based.” I already do, but some websites/platforms don’t play nice on non-Chromium-based browsers due to Google’s monopoly on the web. Sometimes I can afford to not use that website/platform, but unfortunately not always.
  • “Brave’s [insert controversy] makes them unreliable to take services from.” Honestly, I think that if both solutions are as effective that a reason like this might be sufficient to tip the balance in favor of one. Because ultimately this all comes down to trust.
  • "Just use Ungoogled Chromium." Some more knowledgeable people than me advice against it. Though, I’d say I’m open to hear different opinions on this as long as they’re somewhat sophisticated.
  • “Just use [insert another Chromium-based browser].” If it has merits beyond Brave and Chromium with respect to security and privacy, I’ll consider it.

Thanks in advance!

  1. I can be more specific about which distro I prefer using, but I don’t think it matters. I might be wrong though*.
    • qwert230839265026494@sh.itjust.worksOP
      54·
      10 months ago

      Chromium vs Brave? Firefox.

      “Just use Firefox/Librewolf or any other privacy-conscious browser that isn’t Chromium-based.” I already do, but some websites/platforms don’t play nice on non-Chromium-based browsers due to Google’s monopoly on the web. Sometimes I can afford to not use that website/platform, but unfortunately not always.

      😅. Thanks anyways 👍.

      • glad_cat@lemmy.sdf.org
        1·
        9 months ago

        Please list the web sites that are broken on Firefox. People always say this without giving sources.

  • jsdz@lemmy.ml
    4·
    10 months ago

    Having read that hit piece aimed at Ungoogled Chromium, I will continue to use it for the rare occasions when I need something other than Firefox. It makes a few good points that security-conscious users should be aware of (although which of them still apply at present is unknown to me) but it does not look anything like what I would expect from an unbiased and diligent reviewer.

  • Rooki@lemmy.world
    62·
    10 months ago

    Wow chromium vs chromium what a nice comparison. firefox is a real alternative

    • qwert230839265026494@sh.itjust.worksOP
      23·
      10 months ago

      firefox is a real alternative

      “Just use Firefox/Librewolf or any other privacy-conscious browser that isn’t Chromium-based.” I already do, but some websites/platforms don’t play nice on non-Chromium-based browsers due to Google’s monopoly on the web. Sometimes I can afford to not use that website/platform, but unfortunately not always.

      Thanks for chiming in 😅.

      • Rooki@lemmy.world
        31·
        10 months ago

        Could you elaborate on what specific websites? Firefox i had 0 issues, librewolf has to get some tweaks has few incompatibilities like netflix etc…

        • qwert230839265026494@sh.itjust.worksOP
          1·
          10 months ago

          Just a few days ago I tried to pay for flight tickets on flypgs.com. Multiple attempts on Firefox didn’t work, while the first attempt on a Chromium-based one did. It might have been a fluke, but every so often issues like these do happen. And for some reason switching the browser does bear a positive result. YMMV though.

          • Rooki@lemmy.world
            1·
            10 months ago

            Best to do in that case to complain over the email contact. That they fix that shit.

            • njinx@lemmy.world
              2·
              10 months ago

              Yes, that is definitely easier and more effective than opening a different browser for a couple of minutes /s

        • nick@midwest.socialEnglish
          21·
          10 months ago

          Google cloud consoles require chrome for IAP attention. That is a concrete example of Firefox not working on a site.

          I use Firefox, but I also know it has its issues. Don’t be a zealot.

          • kraniax@lemmy.wtf
            11·
            9 months ago

            Google cloud consoles

            those aren’t Firefox issues. it’s google purposefully using chromium only features and not well-supported web standards.

            • nick@midwest.socialEnglish
              11·
              9 months ago

              Page won’t load in Firefox, making it an issue. I don’t care what the root cause is, and also I already knew all of that.

  • Rocha@lm.put.tf
    63·
    10 months ago

    I believe Brave is the most private chromium browser, at least with the installation defaults.

    As for the controversies with the company, there were some at the beginning stages, but I haven’t heard anything new in quite a while.

    Regarding the crypto, vpn, etc bloat, I use Brave on all my devices and all I have to do is hide that stuff after the installation and I’ve never been bothered by pop-ups or similar annoyances. I don’t think it’s more annoying to remove than having to remove the recommended sites and Pocket with Firefox.

    Since you want private browsing, I would also say that a big plus for Brave is that it has built-in Tor browser.

    • qwert230839265026494@sh.itjust.worksOP
      41·
      10 months ago

      I believe Brave is the most private chromium browser, at least with the installation defaults.

      I haven’t come across anything that surpasses its defaults yet within the realm of Chromium-based browsers.

      As for the controversies with the company, there were some at the beginning stages, but I haven’t heard anything new in quite a while.

      Like I said in the original post, those would be secondary reasons after their respective merits in security and privacy had been resolved to a tie. Though, so far, Brave seems to be the clear winner. I would like to thank the Privacy Guides community over at lemmy.one for their engagement and contributions for that*.

      Regarding the crypto, vpn, etc bloat, I use Brave on all my devices and all I have to do is hide that stuff after the installation and I’ve never been bothered by pop-ups or similar annoyances. I don’t think it’s more annoying to remove than Firefox with the recommended sites and Pocket.

      Yeah, the linked article by Privacy Guides in the original post already shows what should be applied. Some kind of hardening seems to be done first by default anyways, it seems*.

      Since you want private browsing, I would also say that a big plus for Brave is that it has built-in Tor browser.

      For whatever it’s worth, the Privacy Guides team is against using it:

      “Brave is not as resistant to fingerprinting as the Tor Browser and far fewer people use Brave with Tor, so you will stand out. Where strong anonymity is required use the Tor Browser.”

  • librecat@lemmy.basedcount.com
    41·
    10 months ago

    Even though I don’t agree with some of the points, I would still hope to see discussion rather than unexplained downvotes.