• 3 Posts
  • 1.54K Comments
Joined 8 months ago
cake
Cake day: November 8th, 2023

help-circle

  • You assumed and misinterpreted everything you could assume and misinterpret in order to paint standard notes in the best possible light.

    the old approach wasn’t very secure or scalable?

    No, the older approach was more scalable, and they made it more difficult to do

    95-99% of the Javascript that has ever run in your browser is open source frameworks or packages

    No, I was not talking about frameworks.

    Your response was so offbase and full of assumptions that I simply edited my original post.

    All FOSS projects have a team of dictators

    And the Standard Notes team makes a lot of bad choices that make self-hosting harder.

    “Just fork it and make your own” is a Hail Mary response… Because most people cannot.


  • Standard Notes wants to charge you money to run open source JavaScript code, including other people’s markdown and spreadsheet editors, on your own server. To do this, they go out of their way to make self-hosting harder.

    1. Standard Notes went out of their way to make it harder to self-host extensions a couple years ago, which IMO was pretty tasteless on its own. Instead of letting you install a single bundle of extensions with one URL, you would have to manually add each extension and then manually update it later.

    2. They opted for charging for other people’s work. Their editor extensions were other people’s work. For example, their rich text editor was somebody else’s rich text editor with a thin wrapper that allowed it to run in Standard Notes. (Using so many other people’s editors also led to a bit of a lack of stylistic direction.)

    3. And then, more recently, they decided to shut off web app access to third-party servers entirely.

    “FOSS” only means so much when they dictate what goes into the source code. Unfortunately.







  • If we take “unlimited unauthenticated API access shouldn’t be possible” for granted, I’m unfortunately not all that technically competent about what can be done next.

    The first thing that comes to mind is treating website access and app access differently, maybe limiting app API access by default for people who haven’t logged in.

    Or creating a separate bot API that’s rolled out across all servers at some point in the future… And I know federation could pose some serious chokepoints here so that’s where my speculation ends.


  • I have a few suggestions for development concerns off the top of my head:

    • Scrub post metadata* after users request its deletion
    • Auto-purge deleted content* rather than letting it sit behind a “deleted” flag (something Facebook got a ton of flak for doing)
    • Auto-purge deleted media*
    • Consider seriously limiting opening data wide for scraping, since the problem is non-consensual scraping, not payment for non-consensual scraping

    * either immediately or, to prevent spam, after some time


  • …And attitudes like this towards privacy will keep Lemmy from progressing to a point where those issues will be fixed.

    I have a fundamental problem with giant corporations scraping user data without user consent. That’s a system-level issue. It doesn’t become “good” just because they get to scrape without consent for free.


  • Lemmy has quite a few unfortunately invasive qualities of its own, including generally needing an email address from you (Reddit does not), having poor privacy and data retention practices, and generally being very messy with who gets to decide what happens with your data and how easily it can be scraped.

    Sure, Reddit sells it… But Lemmy gives it to any web scraper for free.








  • I’m not really a fan of “clean” and “minimalist” launchers when they get to the point of impeding my productivity. And keeping a curated list can tap into muscle memory, improving speed further.

    For example:

    I’ve got 13 apps I can launch with a single tap, 13 more one extra swipe away (unless you count the swipe into my app drawer, which would bring it up to ~32 more).

    Just something to keep in mind when looking for a launcher: you might want to find your definition of fast. If KISS works for you, all the more power to you. But I lament the lack of FOSS launchers that are more Nova-esque.