• 6 Posts
  • 162 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 28th, 2023

help-circle









  • NASA should let private companies do the “easy” stuff so they can focus on bigger and better things. And use the flow of private development money coming from venture capital or share offerings as a multiplier for their budget.

    The numbers for Falcon and Dragon don’t back up what you’re saying. They were developed for less money than it would have taken NASA and are cheaper than other options. They’re also sold to non-NASA customers, which means a reduced unit cost from increased volume.

    • Cargo Dragon is cheaper than Cygnus
    • Crew Dragon is cheaper than Starliner
    • Falcon 9 is cheaper than Atlas V or Vulcan
    • Falcon Heavy is cheaper than Delta IV Heavy

    There’s also the issue of availability and readiness for all of those, where SpaceX wins handily.

    Another example is the CLPS providers, which are expected to cover some of the development money and find more customers to make up that difference. They’re doing entire Lunar lander missions for less than the cost of an Atlas V launch.








  • At least these are “only” the ISS suits, not the Lunar surface suits from Axiom, so this doesn’t make the Artemis situation worse. Hopefully SpaceX can evolve their new suits enough to be useful for space station EVAs for Vast or whoever.

    Setting this up as a task order contract never made sense to me. Firm fixed price for this also doesn’t make sense to me. It’s a development program with 0 commercial customers and no ability to lease them to private customers. What a weird, late, mess.




  • The ISS has always been a source of soft diplomacy, and it’s cool to see the short private missions expand that. It’s cool that Dragon is available and able to make these possible.

    Regarding Gaganyaan to the ISS- their first crewed flight is NET… late 2025? Their timeline could work to get one to the ISS. I wouldn’t be surprised to see them book a flight to a Vast station. They also signed something or other with Blue for Orbital Reef, so that could be their target, too.