Fixed in latest update
Fixed in latest update
Are you planning to open source it at all?
I am also wondering this myself. I don’t fault anyone for not, but may have an impact on my long term commitment with where my interest in this space is.
Also latest updates seemed to fix the issue with fold type phones.
Ok, so you have nothing to worry about. The subtle distiction matters to many, as evident by the engagement the subject has been getting. It’s just about education, it isn’t a case against Lemmy.
It isn’t that the fediverse doesn’t care, it is that the primary focus here is to prevent you from being tracked. How public you are is your responsibility, as it is everywhere, but there is a degree that you have to be more cautious here.
There are discussions on how to mitigate this, but it can’t be entirely solved because it conflicts with other goals such as censorship resistence and community safety.
The comment about EU is the other component. Many instances do not have privacy policies, Lemmy doesn’t provide a default framework, so some admins are temporarily blocking EU if it applies to them. The ones hosted in EU will get rekt if they aren’t or don’t get into compliance. I offer a template to start this process of compliancy.
Everyone can see them if they use kbin and I think Mastodon which Lemmy interoperates with (ie. Kbin users often see and engage with posts on Lemmy and vice versa). Sign up to kbin if you want to see yourself.
All admins have access, and a rouge admin could very easily mine it.
I can see an argument for it, but does make you take pause on how you will use that feature doesn’t it?
Apologies. It can resonate with some, but can definitely be confusing to others. If you want clarity on anything I am happy to try to answer it plainly.
Hey folks, guy in the cross post. Thanks for doing that @hardypart@feddit.de , I feel it is an important discussion for people to be a part of across the Lemmiverse.
Seems there is some positive engagement on here, and maybe a couple that are a bit confused. I’m going to assume they aren’t just curmudgeons because why would you waste time commenting if you weren’t making an expression of interest in good faith, but maybe not ready to fully invest yet?
To expand on the TLDR; many new users are coming from monolith platforms (such as reddit; Meta; etc) into the brave new world of federated platforms (like Lemmy) without fully understanding the difference in privacy principles between these two models. Many, more experienced, users do not understand it fully themselves and they make potentially dangerous assertions, or at least ones that could mislead less experienced users into believing Lemmy behaves in a way that it doesn’t.
It’s all fine and good to say “Everything posted on the internet stays. Never post anything you don’t want public”, but in practice, and especially people coming from monolith platforms, they may make mistakes if they are not highly cognizant of some distinctions between the two models of public, social engagement.
If you are certain you’ll never, ever have any risk of making such a mistake, the subtle distinction won’t matter to you. If you aren’t sure (it is very easy to trip up here) you are going to want to be educated on where some of the potential hazards are, and you will want to be very, very, very careful. Like you never have been before.
Even some of the most confident, let’s call them, “perfectly private posters”, often get a little shook when I inform them their votes are entirely public, when they had previously made an assumption they were not due to familiarity with a monolith platform where votes are private. It seems intuitive that they should be private here, but that is not the case. This is a very prevalent misunderstanding right now, and very eye opening to some.
I much prefer the model of federated because it really gives the user the full control of their privacy to engage to the level they are comfortable with. But it can be very dangerous if not managed appropriately.
I also feel the wider community is not doing a very good job of communicating this, which is validated by the chord it seems to have struck over on Beehaw. But I come with solutions: a haywire, but comprehensive essay on some of the things a user should be aware of. I have also started a project that provides templates for privacy policies so that admins can add accountability to their instances while also protecting themselves.
Anyway, a very complex subject many are still learning to navigate, and not something easily reduced to a tldr; As it is, this version is half the length of the original, and you would have been half way through it by now if you just went to the source.
If you have any questions, I’m here to answer them.
I have had concerns about this since I joined. Personally I don’t mind that the votes are public and can see a case for it, however the wider community is doing a very poor job of informing the users how this all works, and that will result in very bad outcomes.
Lemmy (the wider community) privacy does stink (and how to change that)
Same on Fold 3.
Same here, same device.
Yeah, same here. Just seemed to be worse since the recent block list and thought maybe related, but appears to be just timing.
Lemmy isn’t even at a point 2 minor version yet so it will be awhile before it is stable and these kind of kinks worked out, but this kind of thing is going to somewhat the norm I think, by design.
Beehaw defederated Lemmy.world, and they are both have large communities. Although we federate with them both, depending on who/where it was posted the source of truth may result in not always getting consistent updates from both.
I believe the reality in federated space is you will always want to have an account on all the more active instances, using one local as your primary and monitoring things you want to follow on multiple. Luckily the official app makes it pretty easy to do, and maybe there is another app, or one in the works, that will do a client side merge across accounts.
I think that part is still up to the instance to announce. In the case here at lemmy.ca the admin has made a call to block those on a list another admin has made of problematic instances (seem to be primarily instances that have seen a recent, unexplained spike). Note this is not the issue with Lemmy.world which is not blocked, the issue with them just seems to be either overloaded or general issues with Lemmy or .world right now.
Difference in signup policy creating moderation overhead the reason for the high profile case:
You’ll want to post more detail than
the instance would not work
VM doesn’t boot? Backend doesn’t start? Nginx doesn’t start or returns an error when visiting? Database connection?
I believe .world has, though it still shows up as linked: https://lemmy.ca/instances
However there is another thread here about .world federation issues. I tested it and .world isn’t syncing here.
@smorks does the configuration or tool you are using for this reflect in the linked/blocked page or is it blocked on another level when this +10,000 user block kicks in?
*edit: tested from .ml which has more than 10,000 users and worked. However if it is by “active” user, .ml, behaw below 10,000 where .world is above.
Oh sweet. That is way easier than what I just did. Updated my comment on not knowing.
Yup, that’s the issue. Thanks!
Err. Actually didn’t read column headers. It says linked, so maybe a version issue / some other bug.
Definitely not working from .world as I posted from an account there on this thread and it hasn’t shown up. I haven’t experienced this with any other instance yet, just .world
deleted by creator
There is a sailing community I engage with that is straight Lemmy.ca to Lemmy.world. Seems I get some federation but not all, so probably not a defed issue.
Lemmy.world appears to be running out of date version of Lemmy (boo lemmy.world)
Our admin might just be too on top of things for them to keep up.
*edit: or maybe it is defed https://lemmy.ca/post/919062.
*edit 2: Seems to be, I just tested on this thread from a .world account.
*edit 3: not defed, just .world probably being hammered along with other Lemmy growing pains.
What I have done is set up a lemmy.world account and follow posts I engaged with there if I care to keep up.
Fixed in latest update.