ETA to Israel bombing the three aid corridors? Because we’ve seen that already:
https://www.npr.org/2023/11/17/1213579692/israel-gaza-evacuation-south-attacks
I think he actually got a little worried about the pushback regarding the most recent bombing of aid vans. Like, even the most pro Israeli outlets and groups online were saying “wow… that was a huge fuck up…”
Of course, none of them were acknowledging it was likely intentional. But I think in terms of gauging “are the Israeli people cool with us literally starving civilians to death” IDF leadership got a fairly affirmative “no”.
How do we know it was intentional? Although I guess the practical difference between intentional and callously indifferent is not very large in this context. So maybe it doesn’t matter.
They were specifically told the itinerary of the aid workers.
“All three vehicles were carrying civilians; they were marked as WCK vehicles; and their movements were in full compliance with Israeli authorities, who were aware of their itinerary, route, and humanitarian mission,” WCK said in a statement Thursday.
I’m not sure how it can be accidental if you were told about it in advance.
And even if for a moment, that the person who aimed the guns didn’t know, it was someone’s job to make sure they did. Someone knew.
Someone did but it could still be claimed to be “accidental” if that information didn’t make it to the person performing the attack. I’m not saying that’s what happened but it’s plausible. Though I will say at minimum I doubt they would have done this if they knew how well connected these aid workers were. It would have been politically very foolish.
I think their overall strategy makes it clear that they don’t much care to avoid killing civilians and aid workers that are not well connected. But it’s hard to prove it’s done intentionally.
It’s very hard to prove their intent.
It’s very easy to prove their negligence.
We don’t know that they targeted aid workers. We can certainly say that they killed them without identifying them as valid military targets, because they weren’t.
I completely agree but legally speaking the intentionality does matter in terms of the genocide case, etc. So that’s why I am curious what evidence we have. But intent is almost always the hardest piece of a crime to prove.
legally speaking
Which law?
Because US law requires intent, but I’m not sure ICC/ICJ have the same requirements.
Why are you trying this hard to pretend there is more than one side to this situation? People have given you the facts and you keep snapping back to this CNN passive-voice “we can’t know for sure”.
Because that’s the default response to truth claims that are unproven? I don’t think this hyper-emotional speculation is very helpful personally.
I don’t really care about your emotions or frankly any emotions other than the people directly affected. I’m trying to sort out what is true and false and what can be definitively proven from the available evidence. But there is a ton of misinformation flying around, so I want to be careful about what narratives I endorse, since many false narratives are being used to justify violence and hatred right now.
There are 3 possibilities:
-
Israel internationally bombed a clearly marked aid convoy after being informed of and approving their route.
-
Israel internationally adopted rules of engagement so lax that they allowed for 3 accidental bombings on a clearly marked aid convoy after being informed of and approving their route.
-
All of the above.
The problem for Israel is that all of those possibilities are war crimes.
Well, what they’re going to claim is that war is hard and this happens to everyone, so it’s not intentional at all. Unfortunately, for people predisposed to believe them, this argument can seem quite reasonable. So that’s why we need to rigorously challenge it using as many lines of evidence as possible.
-
We don’t, which is why I say “likely” - but the sheer precision and clear markings on the vehicles makes me doubt the “it was a series of accidents” explanation.
Maybe I interpreted the word intentionally differently than you meant to use it. My understanding of the IDF’s explanation was that they mistakenly thought the vehicles were Hamas. So by intentional I thought you mean they were knowingly killing aid workers.
I think everyone agrees the vehicles were deliberately targeted, but why this was done is open to speculation.
No, we’re of the same mindset. It’s clear the missiles didn’t fall on these vehicles by chance, it’s just up for some debate regarding on if they were deliberately targeted knowing they were aid vehicles or not
I just war game it, disincentive aid, create famine, after everyone is starving the only people not starving are Hamas.
Probably been bombed already
The U.S. has significant leverage over Israel as its main supplier of weapons and military equipment.
They sure don’t seem to, considering they never even explicitly threaten to use that leverage. Even the call, based on a situation that supposedly left Biden anguished, was still an implicit threat. At least based on what’s published.
If Biden wants to actually get any change done he should damn well know that getting rid of Bibi is the only way to do that. The best way to get rid of Bibi is to make the Knesset realize he’s an existential threat to Israel because he’s about to cause the US to cut off support.
Yes, that is a strange quote. It should read “AIPAC has has significant control over who is elected to the U.S. government”.
Did Biden threaten to take away Bibi’s new genocidal toys?
If these corridors open I’m sure that’ll mean the Israelis will have access to new weapons.
So you’re saying these 3 new aid corridors are a bad thing?
The aid corridors are good, the circumstances are not.
Fuck Israel.
USA needs to provide military escorts.
Let Israel kill US troops.
Let us see what happens if they do it again.
History tells us not much will happen https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Liberty_incident
But still…
There’s thousands of trucks right outside Rafah. We don’t need more “aid corridors”. We don’t need more piers to bomb WFC vehicles on. Gaza is like 25 miles long. A truck can drive 25 miles.
Just let the trucks in.
The aid corridors are for the trucks.
War pigs, all of them.
AKA “targeting calibration corridors”.
Biden waits for Israel to kill a bunch of aid workers with no consequences
Biden tells Bibi to “open corridors” for aid into the North.
Now Bibi and Biden can claim they’re “humanitarian” despite knowing most aid workers are too afraid to enter the North.
Liberals are gonna eat this shit up when the biweekly “vote blue no matter who” post rocks up on the front page of lemmy.
